
A DAY after Pakistan pointed
to the “gap” with the United
States in tackling terror, Richard
Holbrooke, America’s special
envoy said the Afghanistan sit ,
uation can’t be settled without
India’s full involvement.
Holbrooke, tasked by
President Barack Obama to
engineer a “regional solution”
to the Afghanistan-Pakistan,
or Af-Pak, region, told the
press that India and the US
had the same goals, but little
coordination in Afghanistan.
Speaking in the presence of
America’s top military official,
Mike Mullen, he insisted on
Wednesday that they were not
visiting the region to negotiate
between India and Pakistan.
“We didn’t come here to ask
India to do anything. We did
not come here with requests,”
Holbrooke said, stressing that
his mission was to “inform and
consult” with Indian officials.
The envoy’s remarks are,
however, at variance with what
US Central Command chief
Gen. David Petraeus said at a
Senate Committee hearing in
Washington on April 1.
Given Islamabad’s focus on
the east, “is there any discussion about urging India and
Pakistan to continue finding a
way forward on Kashmir?”
Colorado Democrat Mark
Udall asked at the hearing.
Petraeus replied: “Together
with my great diplomatic wing
man, Ambassador Richard
Holbrooke, this effort actually
has started. I met with the Indian
national security adviser, for
example, in Munich. We had a
very good discussion. That was
followed up when the foreign
minister of India (actually
Foreign Secretary Shivshankar
Menon) came to Washington
more recently .”
In Delhi, Holbrooke, who
met both Menon and NSA M.K.
Narayanan, went out of his
way to underline that he wasn’t in lecture mode when meeting Indian officials. Holbrooke and Mullen again
emphasised the common problems that South Asia faced and
the need to work together to
address these issues.
“For the first time since partition, India, Pakistan and the
United States face a common
threat, a common challenge
and we have a common task,”
Holbrooke said.
From President Obama
downwards, who recently said
he wouldn’t be issuing any more
blank cheques to Pakistan, to
charges of links between the ISI
and militant outfits, there’s been
a sharp ratcheting up of pressure on Islamabad.
“On the issue of Swat I have
expressed concern. The
Chairman (Mullen) and I met
the people from the area in
order to learn more about
them. It was very difficult and
touching. What’s happening in
Swat has stunned the people of
Pakistan. The attack on the Sri
Lankan cricket team and the
police academy has further
raised concerns,” he said.
Mullen stressed that India’s
cooperation was vital to maintaining stability in South Asia.
“India is a vital leader in the
region. The role that India plays
is absolutely critical,”Mullen said.
Holbrooke also cleared that
there was no talk of US-Pak
nuclear deal saying that the
“subject did not come up”.
“We are still in the first few
months of the new administration. We developed a new strategy in the last seven weeks for
which consulted the Indian government…I came here and several senior Indian government
officials were in Washington and
gave their views. It is now beginning of implementation,” the
special envoy said.
Inputs from V. Krishna in
Washington
tushar@hindustantimes.com
A DAY after Pakistan pointed
to the “gap” with the United
States in tackling terror, Richard
Holbrooke, America’s special
envoy said the Afghanistan sit-
,
uation can’t be settled without
India’s full involvement.
Holbrooke, tasked by
President Barack Obama to
engineer a “regional solution”
to the Afghanistan-Pakistan,
or Af-Pak, region, told the
press that India and the US
had the same goals, but little
coordination in Afghanistan.
Speaking in the presence of
America’s top military official,
Mike Mullen, he insisted on
Wednesday that they were not
visiting the region to negotiate
between India and Pakistan.
“We didn’t come here to ask
India to do anything. We did
not come here with requests,”
Holbrooke said, stressing that
his mission was to “inform and
consult” with Indian officials.
The envoy’s remarks are,
however, at variance with what
US Central Command chief
Gen. David Petraeus said at a
Senate Committee hearing in
Washington on April 1.
Given Islamabad’s focus on
the east, “is there any discus-
sion about urging India and
Pakistan to continue finding a
way forward on Kashmir?”
Colorado Democrat Mark
Udall asked at the hearing.
Petraeus replied: “Together
with my great diplomatic wing
man, Ambassador Richard
Holbrooke, this effort actually
has started. I met with the Indian
national security adviser, for
example, in Munich. We had a
very good discussion. That was
followed up when the foreign
minister of India (actually
Foreign Secretary Shivshankar
Menon) came to Washington
more recently .”
In Delhi, Holbrooke, who
met both Menon and NSA M.K.
Narayanan, went out of his
way to underline that he was-
n’t in lecture mode when meet-
ing Indian officials. Holbrooke and Mullen again
emphasised the common prob-
lems that South Asia faced and
the need to work together to
address these issues.
“For the first time since par-
tition, India, Pakistan and the
United States face a common
threat, a common challenge
and we have a common task,”
Holbrooke said.
From President Obama
downwards, who recently said
he wouldn’t be issuing any more
blank cheques to Pakistan, to
charges of links between the ISI
and militant outfits, there’s been
a sharp ratcheting up of pres-
sure on Islamabad.
“On the issue of Swat I have
expressed concern. The
Chairman (Mullen) and I met
the people from the area in
order to learn more about
them. It was very difficult and
touching. What’s happening in
Swat has stunned the people of
Pakistan. The attack on the Sri
Lankan cricket team and the
police academy has further
raised concerns,” he said.
Mullen stressed that India’s
cooperation was vital to main-
taining stability in South Asia.
“India is a vital leader in the
region. The role that India plays
is absolutely critical,”Mullen said.
Holbrooke also cleared that
there was no talk of US-Pak
nuclear deal saying that the
“subject did not come up”.
“We are still in the first few
months of the new administra-
tion. We developed a new strat-
egy in the last seven weeks for
which consulted the Indian gov-
ernment…I came here and sev-
eral senior Indian government
officials were in Washington and
gave their views. It is now begin-
ning of implementation,” the
special envoy said.
Inputs from V. Krishna in
Washington
tushar@hindustantimes.com