
THERE IT was, the e-mail he
had long dreamt of: “You have
been accepted into the Yale
School of Business, class of
2011.” It was the culmination of
a 10-year-old dream for Soumitra
Sharma. “I’d wanted to study at
an Ivy League university since
I was in secondary school. I was
elated,” says the 25-year-old, formerly an assistant manager
with Deloitte.
But in April, Sharma will be
packing his bags for Hyderabad,
not New Haven, Connecticut
state where the top business
school is located.
“It was a hard decision, but
I’m attending ISB (Indian School
of Business) instead. Going to
the US in this economy is a big
risk, even with a top business
school like Yale,” he says.
Sharma is not alone. Along
with him are 34 other students
from ISB’s incoming class who
have rejected top American
schools. Last year, there were
only 15 such students. “The eco
nomic situation seems to be a
huge factor in the way students
are choosing business schools
this year,” says Anoop Kumar, a
Bangalore-based education consultant.
And it’s not just India-based
employees who are choosing
India over the US. “One of my
clients is an American passportholder who gave up the
Anderson School of Business at
UCLA for ISB,” says Kumar.
Vishal Chopra, a 26-year-old
engineer from San Francisco,
will also be heading back to
Hyderabad, after turning down
the Fuqua School of Business
at Duke University . “The Obama government
has adopted a scarily protectionist tone by not allowing federal-aided companies to hire
H1B visa-holders. Now even
international students aren’t
finding internships. How can
I pay back a Rs 70 lakh loan
without a job?” he asks.
Another factor is the sudden
scarcity of loans for internationals. Last October, Citibank
withdrew its loan-assistance
programme that allowed internationals to take loans without American co-signors. “All
the top schools had tie-ups with
Citibank. Suddenly the funds
seem to be drying up,” says
Kumar.
According to figures
released by GMAC (the body
that administers the GMAT
test required for international MBA applications), there
has been a dramatic decrease
in the number of Indian students sending their scores to
American schools. In 2004, the
Harvard Business School
(HBS) was the top destination
for Indian GMAT reports,
while ISB was at the 10th slot.
By 2008, ISB had become the
top destination while HBS had
dropped to number two.
ISB’s dean Ajit Rangnekar
says, “The ISB has grown in
popularity and acceptance
among its international peers
and has become a good choice
for students looking for topquality schools in India.”
But ISB’s gain also signals
the death of a long-cherished
Indian dream: the muchdesired foreign degree.
Srinivas, a 25-year old first
generation entrepreneur from
a small village in Andhra
Pradesh, would know. He
recently rejected the Kellogg
School of Business (one of the
top five business schools in
the world) for ISB. “With the
economy the way it is, I’d
rather play it safe with ISB,”
he says.
riddhi.shah@hindustantimes.com
THERE IT was, the e-mail he
had long dreamt of: “You have
been accepted into the Yale
School of Business, class of
2011.” It was the culmination of
a 10-year-old dream for Soumitra
Sharma. “I’d wanted to study at
an Ivy League university since
I was in secondary school. I was
elated,” says the 25-year-old, for-
merly an assistant manager
with Deloitte.
But in April, Sharma will be
packing his bags for Hyderabad,
not New Haven, Connecticut
state where the top business
school is located.
“It was a hard decision, but
I’m attending ISB (Indian School
of Business) instead. Going to
the US in this economy is a big
risk, even with a top business
school like Yale,” he says.
Sharma is not alone. Along
with him are 34 other students
from ISB’s incoming class who
have rejected top American
schools. Last year, there were
only 15 such students. “The eco-
nomic situation seems to be a
huge factor in the way students
are choosing business schools
this year,” says Anoop Kumar, a
Bangalore-based education con-
sultant.
And it’s not just India-based
employees who are choosing
India over the US. “One of my
clients is an American passport-
holder who gave up the
Anderson School of Business at
UCLA for ISB,” says Kumar.
Vishal Chopra, a 26-year-old
engineer from San Francisco,
will also be heading back to
Hyderabad, after turning down
the Fuqua School of Business
at Duke University . “The Obama government
has adopted a scarily protec-
tionist tone by not allowing fed-
eral-aided companies to hire
H1B visa-holders. Now even
international students aren’t
finding internships. How can
I pay back a Rs 70 lakh loan
without a job?” he asks.
Another factor is the sudden
scarcity of loans for interna-
tionals. Last October, Citibank
withdrew its loan-assistance
programme that allowed inter-
nationals to take loans with-
out American co-signors. “All
the top schools had tie-ups with
Citibank. Suddenly the funds
seem to be drying up,” says
Kumar.
According to figures
released by GMAC (the body
that administers the GMAT
test required for internation-
al MBA applications), there
has been a dramatic decrease
in the number of Indian stu-
dents sending their scores to
American schools. In 2004, the
Harvard Business School
(HBS) was the top destination
for Indian GMAT reports,
while ISB was at the 10th slot.
By 2008, ISB had become the
top destination while HBS had
dropped to number two.
ISB’s dean Ajit Rangnekar
says, “The ISB has grown in
popularity and acceptance
among its international peers
and has become a good choice
for students looking for top-
quality schools in India.”
But ISB’s gain also signals
the death of a long-cherished
Indian dream: the much-
desired foreign degree.
Srinivas, a 25-year old first
generation entrepreneur from
a small village in Andhra
Pradesh, would know. He
recently rejected the Kellogg
School of Business (one of the
top five business schools in
the world) for ISB. “With the
economy the way it is, I’d
rather play it safe with ISB,”
he says.
riddhi.shah@hindustantimes.com